How will I know?
About ten years ago, I was sitting in an office listening to an entertaining interaction between an engineer and the CEO of the startup I was working at. The engineer wanted to work from home a few days a week. The CEO was not convinced.
“How will I know if you’re working?” he asked.
Without so much as a beat, the engineer responded “How do you know I’m working when I’m here?”
This goes to the heart of much of what followed RTO after Covid. The mandates were seen to promote visibility, and the visibility didn’t actually tell the organisation anything. Presenteeism is not the same as value creation. But you can count bums on seats.
In the four years since the pandemic, mandates have increased and positions have hardened. A working paper on RTO mandates by the University of Pittsburgh found that managers use RTO mandates to re-assert control, with no evidence of increased firm performance, while employee satisfaction falls.
In the US, things appear to have stabilised at around 52% employees being hybrid, 26% fully remote, and 22% fully on-site. Between 2024 and 2025, mandated in-office days increased by 12%, while attendance has increased between 1% and 3%. Gallup has found that “six in 10 employees with remote-capable jobs want a hybrid work arrangement. About one-third prefer fully remote work, and less than 10% prefer to work on-site.”
So, we all have positions. Badge swipes are counted. Reminder emails are sent. But what are we “returning” to?
Back to the future
When people came back to the same banks of white desks they’d seen before the pandemic, things had changed. They’d spent two years learning to build relationships online. The office, which had felt full before, now didn’t have enough people in it to recreate the atmosphere. Occupancy rates lag below what they were pre-pandemic, and “the sustained gap between current office occupancy and pre-pandemic levels signals that hybrid and flexible working arrangements have become entrenched and are unlikely to revert to pre-2020 norms fully.” Vendor data has found that a quarter of desks go unused on any given day.
With workers having as many meetings online as they do in person, it’s debatable whether the organisation ever fully returned to the office at all. The “return” branding is important here. It shows a seam in the logic. A lot of people hired during the pandemic weren’t returning anywhere. They were experiencing in-office culture at their new employer for the first time.
Half-empty offices won’t build connection. Having people sit together in rows of desks is only going to get you so far.
The thing that happened before that really needs re-creating isn’t the team meeting, and it’s not free pizza at in-person workshops.
It’s the opportunity to collaborate with people outside your team. When Microsoft’s US workforce went fully remote in 2020, communications data showed that employee networks became more static and siloed, with fewer bridges between different parts of the company. What moved online was keeping hold of the people you already knew. You don’t get the opportunity to overhear conversations when you only communicate via video call. Co-location offers more opportunities for cross-team collaboration and accidental influence.
There are costs and benefits. A working paper from NBER found that “sitting near teammates increases coding feedback by 18.3% and improves code quality”, particularly for junior engineers. The other side of that coin is that senior engineers spend less time writing code, presumably because they are providing that feedback. So, we see relationships form, but at the cost of the attention of our most expensive people.
Connection cuts both ways. Many of us who didn’t see the benefit of the office overlooked the opportunities. Many of those who pushed for mandated attendance under-appreciated the costs. People can count commuters. Nobody is measured for fostering connection.
No column is complete without....
The generative AI revolution has changed the way leaders work. Discussions and rubberducking that once happened in rooms now happen with models. Leaders use generative AI at work more than the people who work for them. Frequent use among leaders has risen from 17 per cent to 44 per cent since mid-2023. Did this give rise to leaders feeling less connected than they did before? This hasn’t been counted yet.
Leadership work is historically based around human interactions. The push and pull of argument. The agreement of strategy. Now, humans do that increasingly with a copilot instead of a colleague. Has the absence of humans discombobulated leadership? Is that now driving the push for people to be in the office?
The way we do things around here?
Pre-Covid, having just joined another organisation, I was invited to a meeting with a VP of Engineering. One of my team had asked to work from home a couple of days a week. I sat there, wondering why I was in the room. I didn’t understand there was a question. I’d come from a hybrid role and had worked remotely not long before that.
“We’re an in-office culture,” said the VP, and I understood what I had been missing. This was an organisation that confused co-location with connection.
There’s no doubt that part of what drove the original RTO campaign was a reaching back for how things used to be. For some leaders, there is a sincere belief in co-location driving connection. That belief leads them to consider the sudden shift to remote work as an interruption rather than an opportunity. In turn, that belief made them think that everyone would be keen to return to the office.
Connection is talked about frequently. In the emails reminding people of company policy. In the all-hands and the cultural norms. But little effort is put into making it happen beyond calling people back to a location and hoping for the best. Meanwhile, employee networks grow or wither based on people’s ability to reach beyond their silos.
My former CEO wanted to know whether people were working. He counted the people he could see. Nobody counts how many people know who to call when something breaks, and that is the number that would have told him something.



